Blog

Red Hook NY Real Estate Market Trends – September 2025

Insights for Both Buyers & Sellers

The Red Hook, NY housing market for September 2025 continues to show its dynamic nature this fall—where opportunity meets strategy for both buyers and sellers. With inventory tightening and prices showing strong momentum, understanding these shifts can help you make confident real estate decisions.

During the month there were 11 sales with a median dollar square feet of $289 and total dollar sales volume of $10.84 millions.  The median property value in Red Hook in September was $517,550 up slightly at .1% over August.

Red Hook NY Housing Market for September 2025: Balanced but Shifting

In September 2025, Red Hook’s housing market registered a 4.7-month supply of inventory, reflecting a balanced market that slightly favors sellers. Inventory dipped 4% from August and 31% year-over-year, signaling fewer homes available—and more competition among active buyers.

Across the market, 47 active listings show a median list price of $699,000, while 15 new listings entered with a median price of $795,000. Meanwhile, 12 pending sales posted a median list price of $722,000, suggesting healthy buyer activity across mid-to-high price points.

 Prices and Pace: Strong Demand Driving Growth

The median sold price jumped 31% month-over-month to $723,000, showing growing buyer confidence and appreciation potential.
Homes are also moving faster—spending a median of just 42 days on the market, down 39% from August. And with a 99.11% sold-to-list price ratio, sellers are achieving nearly full asking price on average.

These numbers paint a clear picture: motivated buyers are out there, and well-priced, well-presented homes are selling swiftly

For Buyers: Act Strategically in a Tightening Market

With fewer listings and faster sales, buyers should be prepared to act decisively when the right home appears.

• Do your homework early: Get pre-approved and know your budget.
• Watch for new listings: With median prices around $700K, opportunities exist across a range of price points.
• Think long-term: Low inventory could drive future price growth—making this a strategic time to buy in Red Hook.

Red Hook remains one of Dutchess County’s most desirable communities, known for its charming village center, scenic landscapes, and easy access to cultural hotspots like Bard College and Poets’ Walk Park.

• At 4.8 months of available inventory, the inventory is down -17.8% month over month, and -16.7% from last year.   This was a signal, fewer homes are available. Buyers may want to act quickly, while sellers could benefit from reduced competition

For Sellers: Market Momentum Is on Your Side

If you’ve been considering selling, market timing couldn’t be better. With inventory shrinking and demand staying strong, sellers are well-positioned to achieve competitive offers.

• Price with precision: Homes listed near the $700K–$725K range are seeing strong engagement.
• Stage to impress: Declutter, freshen up key spaces, and highlight your home’s lifestyle appeal.
• Capitalize on speed: The drop in days on market means the right listing strategy can yield quick results.

With the median sold price up 31% and homes selling close to list price, Red Hook sellers can step confidently into fall knowing buyers are ready to move.

Life in Red Hook: Small-Town Charm, Big Appeal

Red Hook is Dutchess County’s most northern community, known for its charming village center, scenic landscapes, and easy access to cultural hotspots like Bard College and Poets’ Walk Park.

Final Takeaway for: Red Hook NY Housing Market for September 2025

Whether you’re buying or selling, Red Hook’s September 2025 market is defined by balance—but leaning toward opportunity.
Buyers benefit from stable conditions and a strong local lifestyle; sellers gain from rising prices and quick sales. In short, it’s a great time to make your move.

Thinking about buying or selling in Red Hook?
Let’s connect!

📞 Contact Jennifer Fivelsdal | Real Estate Broker of JFIVE Homes Realty | 845-594-9947 | jennifer@jfivehomes.com, for personalized market insight and expert real estate guidance.

*** Data provided by  Realtor Property  Resource LLC (RPR) – Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.